.

PAINTMYWALLS

Paints -
Mineral (Natural) vs Synthetic

In the below section, we shall be discussing mineral paints from various perspectives-
>> Why mineral paints?
>> How it is better compared to the other natural Paints?
>> How it compares to synthetic Paints
>> … more

FAQ

Most frequent questions and answers

Mineral-based paints are a type of paint that use natural minerals as their primary components, rather than synthetic chemicals. These paints are known for their durability, eco-friendliness, and unique aesthetic qualities. There are several types of mineral-based paints, each with its own characteristics:

Mineral-based paints typically use natural minerals and inorganic pigments as their primary     components. Common types include silicate paints, lime paints, and natural mineral paints.

Environmentally Friendly – One of the major benefits of using mineral paint is that it is environmentally friendly. Unlike conventional paints, mineral paint does not contain harmful chemicals or volatile organic compounds (VOCs), making it non-toxic and safe for both human health and the environment. Additionally, mineral paint is biodegradable and does not contribute to environmental pollution

Long-lasting Durability- Mineral paint offers long-lasting durability that can withstand the test of time. It creates a strong bond with surfaces, resulting in a finish that is resistant to fading, chipping, and cracking. This makes mineral paint an ideal choice for both interior and exterior applications, especially in high-traffic areas or areas exposed to harsh weather conditions.

Breathability – Another notable benefit of mineral paint is its breathability. Unlike many synthetic paints, mineral paint allows moisture to evaporate from surfaces, preventing the growth of mold and mildew. It also provides a breathable barrier that allows substrates to retain their natural moisture balance, reducing the risk of moisture-related issues such as peeling or blistering.

Mineral paints are also commonly referred to as:

  • Silicate Paints: This term is used specifically for paints that use potassium silicate as the binder and is the most widely used natural paint.
  • Lime Paints: This term is used for paints made with slaked lime (calcium hydroxide) as the primary binder.

The primary binder in Mineral/Silicate paints is potassium silicate (also known as water glass). It helps the paint adhere well to mineral surfaces and allows for breathability.

Mineral-based paints are best suited for porous and mineral-based surfaces such as masonry, concrete, brick, and plaster. They are less ideal for non-porous surfaces or those treated with synthetic materials.

Yes, mineral-based paints are generally considered environmentally friendly. They use natural ingredients and produce fewer volatile organic compounds (VOCs) compared to all synthetic paints.

Mineral-based paints are known for their durability and resistance to weathering, mold, and mildew. Silicate paints, for example, form a strong bond with mineral surfaces and are highly resistant to fading and wear.

Yes, mineral-based paints can be used and very safe for indoor usage. As VOC is very less, kids or elderly can be inside the room while painting. As it is based on minerals, it is almost odourless and harmless. Apart from many other advantages discussed in other sections here, it becomes perfect solution particularly in areas where paint breathability is desired, such as on walls with high moisture levels.

None, in particular. As will be typical to all painting applications, proper surface preparations are needed to ensure good adhesion. This may include cleaning the surface, repairing any damage, and sometimes applying a primer.

Good mineral paints becomes very hard after curing. And it does not break down under UV radiations or other typical damaging effects of atmosphere. Because of these two and few other reasons like no static charges, dirt does not/ cannot adhere to mineral-based paints, unlike other synthetic paints available in Indian Market. As there is ‘adhesion’, such dirt typically is washed off with wind or rain.

Typically, a good mineral paints is virtually maintenance free for years!! And if some accidental damages do happen, touch-ups are a breeze because of the underlying inorganic material consistency (compared to patches that are likely to be visible in case of synthetic paints).

The main types of mineral-based paints are silicate paints and lime paints. Both have unique characteristics and applications:

  • Silicate Paints

Binder: Potassium silicate (water glass).

Characteristics: Silicate paints form a chemical bond with the mineral substrate, creating a durable, breathable coating. They are known for their excellent adhesion, resistance to weathering, and UV stability. You compare the properties to that of a typical sand.

Finish: Typically matte or slightly satin.

Applications: Ideal for exterior masonry, concrete, and plaster. They have typically been used on historic buildings and in areas where breathability is important to prevent moisture damage and their look and shine remains undamaged over years.

  • Lime Paints

Binder: Slaked lime (calcium hydroxide), sometimes combined with water and natural pigments.

Characteristics: Lime paints are highly breathable and flexible, allowing them to adapt to changes in temperature and humidity. They have a unique, soft, matte finish and are less prone to cracking and peeling.

Finish: Matte with a soft, natural texture.

Applications: Commonly used for traditional and historic restorations, as well as on surfaces where vapour permeability is important. Suitable for both interior and exterior applications.

The key difference between the above two Mineral-based paints are as follows:-

  • Binder Material: Silicate paints use potassium silicate, while lime paints use slaked lime.
  • Adhesion and Durability: Silicate paints form a strong chemical bond with mineral surfaces, making them highly durable. Lime paints offer flexibility and breathability but may not adhere as strongly to non-mineral surfaces.
  • Finish and Texture: Silicate paints tend to have a more consistent finish, while lime paints often produce a more textured, natural look.
  • Applications: Silicate paints are best for exterior masonry and concrete. Lime paints are ideal for traditional applications and historical restorations.

The Benefits for using mineral-based paints over synthetic paints are :-

  1. Environmental Friendliness

Low VOCs: Mineral-based paints generally have lower levels of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) compared to many synthetic paints, which makes them less harmful to the environment and indoor air quality.

Natural Ingredients: They use natural minerals and pigments, which reduces the reliance on synthetic chemicals and helps minimize their environmental impact.

  1. Durability and Longevity

Weather Resistance: Silicate paints, in particular, are known for their durability and resistance to weathering, UV rays, and pollutants. They bond chemically with mineral surfaces, creating a long-lasting finish.

Breathability: Lime paints and some mineral paints are highly breathable, which helps prevent moisture build-up and reduces the risk of mold and mildew.

  1. Aesthetic Qualities

Natural Appearance: Mineral-based paints often have a unique, natural appearance. Lime paints, for example, provide a soft, matte finish with a distinctive texture that is valued in historical and traditional contexts.

Colour Stability: Mineral pigments are generally more stable and less prone to fading over time compared to synthetic dyes.

  1. Application and Maintenance

Low Maintenance: Due to their durability and resistance to mold and mildew, mineral-based paints often require less maintenance compared to some synthetic alternatives.

Ease of Application: While mineral-based paints can sometimes be more challenging to apply, they often adhere well to properly prepared surfaces and can be applied with traditional painting techniques.

  1. Health and Safety

Reduced Chemical Exposure: Lower VOC content and the absence of harmful solvents make mineral-based paints a safer option for both the environment and the people applying them.

Non-Toxic: Many mineral-based paints are free from toxic chemicals found in some synthetic paints, contributing to better indoor air quality.

  1. Compatibility with Historic Restoration

Authenticity: Lime paints and some mineral-based paints are preferred for historic restorations because they closely mimic traditional materials used in older buildings and are compatible with historic construction methods.

  1. Moisture Management

Breathability: The high breathability of lime paints and some other mineral-based paints allows surfaces to “breathe,” which helps to manage moisture levels and reduce the risk of trapped moisture causing damage.

The breakdown of the suitability of Silicate Paints for various surfaces are as follows:

  1. Suitable Surfaces:

Masonry: Concrete, brick, and stone surfaces.

Plaster: Mineral-based plasters and renders.

  1. Not Ideal For:

Non-mineral surfaces: Wood, metal, and synthetic surfaces may not provide adequate adhesion or may require special primers.

Mineral-based paints generally perform well in a variety of climates due to their inherent properties, though their performance can vary depending on the specific type of mineral paint and environmental conditions. Here’s how they typically fare in different climates:

  1. Dry Climates – Mineral-based paints, especially silicate paints, perform very well in dry climates. Their breathability helps manage moisture levels, preventing issues like blistering or peeling that can occur when moisture is trapped. The durability and resistance to UV rays of mineral paints contribute to long-lasting performance, even in intense sunlight.
  2. Wet and Humid Climates – effective in humid conditions due to their breathability and resistance to mold. However, they must be applied to well-prepared surfaces to avoid issues.
  3. Cold Climates – Performs well if the surface is properly prepared and cured before application. They can withstand freeze-thaw cycles and remain durable in cold weather.
  4. Hot and Sunny Climates – Excellent performance due to their UV resistance and durability. They are less likely to fade or deteriorate under intense sunlight.

General Considerations

  • Breathability: The high breathability of mineral-based paints helps in managing moisture and temperature fluctuations, which is beneficial in varying climates.
  • Surface Preparation: Proper surface preparation is crucial regardless of climate. Ensuring that surfaces are clean, dry, and appropriately primed will improve paint adhesion and performance.
  • Application Conditions: Mineral-based paints should be applied under the recommended conditions for temperature and humidity to ensure optimal curing and performance.

Mineral-based paints are generally known for emitting very low levels of volatile organic compounds (VOCs) compared to traditional paints. These paints use natural minerals and inorganic pigments, and their composition minimizes the need for organic solvents. While they may have some minimal VOCs due to trace amounts of additives or binders, they are typically much lower in VOCs than conventional paints. This makes them a popular choice for environmentally conscious projects and indoor spaces where air quality is a concern.

Silicate paint offers superior adhesion and longevity due to its chemical bonding and resistance to external factors. It’s particularly suited for harsh weather conditions and demanding applications, whereas other natural paints might excel in different contexts or have specific benefits and limitations. Given all other practical consideration, Silicate based mineral paints are the only viable natural paints which are cost effective and potentially can last forever, without any harmful side effects compared to traditional/ synthetic paints.

Mineral-based paints offer a range of finish options, though the availability can vary depending on the specific type of paint and the manufacturer. Here’s an overview of the typical finishes you can find with mineral-based paints:

  1. Matte (Flat) Finish

Characteristics: A matte or flat finish absorbs light, resulting in a non-reflective, velvety appearance. It is excellent at hiding surface imperfections and is often used for its aesthetic appeal.

Applications: Ideal for interior walls and ceilings where a subtle, non-shiny look is desired. It’s also used in historical restorations for an authentic look.

  1. Eggshell Finish

Characteristics: Eggshell finishes have a slight sheen, providing a soft, velvety appearance that reflects a bit more light than matte finishes. They offer a balance between a matte and a semi-gloss finish.

Applications: Suitable for interior walls in high-traffic areas or rooms where some durability and washability are needed. It’s also used for its subtle luster that adds depth to the colour.

  1. Satin Finish

Characteristics: Satin finishes offer a smooth, even sheen with moderate reflectivity. They provide a slightly glossy appearance without being too shiny.

Applications: Often used for both interior and exterior surfaces, including walls, trim, and cabinetry. It is popular in areas where durability and easy cleaning are important.

  1. Gloss Finish

Characteristics: Gloss finishes are highly reflective and offer a shiny, glass-like appearance. They enhance colour depth and can highlight architectural details.

Applications: Commonly used for trim, mouldings, and metal surfaces. It can also be used on exterior surfaces to provide a durable, water-resistant finish.

  1. Semi-Gloss Finish

Characteristics: Semi-gloss finishes offer a moderate level of shine, reflecting more light than satin finishes but less than full gloss.

Applications: Suitable for high-traffic areas, kitchens, and bathrooms where durability and ease of cleaning are desired. It’s also used for trim and cabinetry.

Synthetic means artificially created or produced by humans through chemical processes i.e. they are not derived from natural sources like plants, animals, or minerals. These paints are made from synthetic polymers like acrylic, latex, or alkyd resins, which are typically used as binders. They are versatile, durable, and widely used for various applications. Other details are discussed in below section.

While both types of paints have their uses and benefits, between the two modern synthetic paints are often preferred for their improved properties including environmental and health profiles.

  • Synthetic Paints: Typically feature modern formulations with lower VOC levels, faster drying times, and easier clean-up. They are designed to address some of the environmental and health issues associated with conventional paints.
  • Conventional Paints: Include older formulations like traditional oil-based paints, which are known for their durability but often have higher VOC levels and more complex application and disposal requirements.

Synthetic paints typically include formulations like acrylic, vinyl, and polyurethane paints. These are often water-based or use synthetic resins as binders.

Negative Effects

  • Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs)

VOC: Modern synthetic paints, especially water-based ones, generally have lower VOC levels compared to traditional oil-based paints. However, they still release VOCs, which can contribute to indoor air pollution and health issues.

Health Impact: Exposure to VOCs can lead to respiratory problems, headaches, and other health issues, although water-based synthetics typically have reduced risks compared to oil-based paints.

  • Environmental Impact

VOC: While newer ones often have lower VOCs, they can still contribute to environmental pollution if not disposed of properly. They may also contain chemicals that can be harmful if released into the environment.

Waste: Disposal of synthetic paints and their containers can contribute to landfill waste if not recycled correctly.

  • Durability and Performance Issues

Some synthetic paints, particularly lower-quality formulations, may not be as durable or might peel, crack, or fade more quickly under certain conditions.

  • Odour

Generally have lower odour compared to oil-based paints but can still emit some fumes, especially during and shortly after application.

Mineral-based paints are generally considered more eco-friendly as they use natural materials and emit fewer volatile organic compounds (VOCs). They are often biodegradable and have a lower environmental impact.

Synthetic paints can have a higher environmental impact due to the chemicals and solvents they contain. They may release more VOCs, which can contribute to air pollution and health issues.

Mineral-based paints are known for their durability and breathability, which makes them good for historic buildings or structures exposed to the elements. They can be more resistant to weathering and the better ones can last for generations.

Synthetic paints often provide a more flexibility in terms of availability, finish etc.

Mineral-based paints often provide a matte or slightly textured finish, which can be desirable for certain architectural styles. They can also age gracefully, developing a unique patina over time.

Synthetic paints offer a wide range of finishes, including high gloss, semi-gloss, and satin. They can achieve a uniform appearance and are available in a broad spectrum of colours.

Mineral-based paints can sometimes be little more expensive due to their natural ingredients and the specialized application techniques required.

Synthetic paints might be less expensive and more widely available, but the costs can vary depending on the type of synthetic paint and its quality.

Mineral-based paints can be more compatible with certain building materials, like stone and masonry, and may help to regulate moisture.

Synthetic paints might be more versatile but can sometimes trap moisture if not applied correctly, which could potentially cause issues with the underlying materials over time

Mineral-based paints are generally good at handling extreme weather conditions due to their breathability. They can resist cracking and peeling being penetrative by design. They are also more resistant to UV rays and weathering.

Synthetic paints might be less resistant to UV rays and weathering, making them unsuitable for areas with intense sun or harsh weather conditions.

Synthetic refers to substances or materials that are artificially created through chemical or industrial processes rather than occurring naturally. These materials are designed and manufactured to achieve specific properties or functions.

A polymer is a large molecule composed of repeating structural units called monomers, which are chemically bonded together to form long chains. Polymers can be either natural (occurring in nature) or synthetic (man-made).

In the context of paints, generally all widely available synthetic paints are made of polymers.

Synthetic paints are complex formulations designed to achieve specific performance characteristics. The binder forms the film that holds the paint together, pigments provide colour, solvents make the paint workable, additives enhance performance, and fillers adjust texture and coverage. Each component plays a critical role in the overall quality and functionality of the paint.

Synthetic paints can potentially be harmful due to the presence of certain chemicals and compounds used in their formulation.

Synthetic paints can pose several potential health risks due to the chemicals they contain. Here’s a detailed overview of these risks and their potential effects:

  1. Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs)

Health Risks: Short-Term: Exposure to VOCs can cause respiratory issues, such as coughing, throat irritation, and shortness of breath. It can also lead to headaches, dizziness, and nausea.

Long-Term: Prolonged exposure to high levels of VOCs may contribute to more serious health problems, including liver and kidney damage, and may even be linked to certain types of cancer.

  1. Solvents

Health Risks: Short-Term: Inhalation of solvent fumes can cause respiratory irritation, headaches, dizziness, and nausea.

Long-Term: Chronic exposure can lead to more severe health issues, such as neurological damage, liver and kidney damage, and other systemic effects. Some solvents are classified as neurotoxins and can affect cognitive and motor functions.

  1. Heavy Metals

Health Risks:

Lead: Exposure to lead can result in developmental and neurological impairments, particularly in children. It can also cause anemia and high blood pressure.

Cadmium: Cadmium exposure can lead to kidney damage, respiratory problems, and is considered a carcinogen.

Chromium: Some forms of chromium can cause respiratory issues, skin irritation, and are also classified as carcinogens.

  1. Formaldehyde

Health Risks: Short-Term: Exposure to formaldehyde can cause respiratory problems, such as coughing and throat irritation.

Long-Term: It is classified as a human carcinogen and long-term exposure may increase the risk of developing cancers, particularly of the nasopharynx and leukemia.

  1. Additives

Health Risks: Varies by Additive: Some additives can cause allergic reactions, skin irritation, or respiratory issues, depending on their nature and concentration.

The choice between mineral-based and synthetic paints should consider both initial costs and long-term performance. Mineral-based paints may have a little higher upfront cost but can provide greater durability and lower maintenance costs over time.

Synthetic paints are generally more affordable initially and offer a wide range of options, but their long-term costs may be higher due to more frequent maintenance and repaints.

The difference between Synthetic (Polymer) Paints vs Mineral Paints are discussed below.
Properties  Polymer-Based Paints Mineral-Based Paints
Composition These paints are made from synthetic polymers like acrylic, latex, or alkyd resins. These paints use Synthetic polymers (such as acrylics) as binders. They are versatile, durable, and widely used for various applications. These paints are made from natural minerals such as limestone, clay, and silicates. Utilize natural mineral pigments (e.g., iron oxide, titanium dioxide) as colorants. They often have a more traditional and eco-friendly composition
UV Resistance They may require UV-resistant additives to prevent fading over time. Natural mineral pigments inherently possess UV resistance and won’t fade easily.
Adhesion Mechanism Adhere through adhesive bonding with the substrate. React chemically with the substrate, creating a stronger bond².
Finish Often have a smooth, modern matte finish Tend to have a chalky matte finish, sometimes described as a “country matte” look.
Environmental Impact Often contain volatile organic compounds (VOCs) and other chemicals that can be harmful to the environment Generally eco-friendly, with low or no VOCs, and are biodegradable.
Durability Durable and resistant to weathering, but may degrade over time due to UV exposure. Highly durable and UV-resistant, making them ideal for outdoor applications
Breathability Less breathable, which can trap moisture and lead to issues like mold and mildew Highly breathable, allowing moisture to evaporate and preventing mold growth
Adhesion Excellent adhesion to a variety of surfaces, including metal, wood, and plastic Strong adhesion to mineral surfaces like brick, stone, and plaster
Application Easy to apply with brushes, rollers, or sprayers and dry quickly Require more surface preparation and may need specific application techniques
Finish Finish Available in a wide range of finishes, from matte to high gloss Typically have a matte or satin finish, with a natural, earthy appearance Typically have a matte or satin finish, with a natural, earthy appearance
Color Stability Colors may fade over time due to UV exposure Colors remain stable and vibrant for longer periods
Cost Generally more affordable and widely available Can be more expensive due to the natural ingredients and specialized production processes.
Health Impact May contain harmful chemicals that can affect indoor air quality Non-toxic and safer for indoor environments
Differences in simple terms:
  • Film and look: Separate layer, Plastic-like coating
  • Breathability: Doesn’t let much air through, like a plastic bag.
  • Water Resistance: Water just rolls off, like a raincoat.
  • Durability: Lasts a long time, resists wear and tear.
  • Washability: Easy to clean, like wiping a table.
  • Finish: Many options – shiny, flat, or in between.
  • VOCs: Less smelly fumes
  • Price: More expensive
  • Drying Time: Dries quickly
  • Best For: Most interior and exterior surfaces
  • Film and look: No separate layer, Natural, earthy coating
  • Breathability: Lets walls breathe, like a cotton shirt
  • Water Resistance: Some water resistance, but not as good as polymer
  • Durability: Very long-lasting, can even get stronger over time
  • Washability: Can be cleaned, but not as easy as polymer
  • Finish: Mostly flat or matte
  • VOCs: Very little to no smell
  • Price: Less expensive
  • Drying Time: Takes longer to dry
  • Best For: Interior walls, especially in damp areas, and some exterior masonry
  • Talk to an Expert Now

    *8am to 8pm All Days

    Get a Free Quote on WhatsApp

    BOOK NOW

    Fill in your details and we’ll get back to you in no time.

    let's talk!

    You'll Receive a Call Back Shortly